Sutton RSS Feed


Respected Sutton church minister Rev Wan Shin and family to be deported


A respected church minister and his family are to be deported back to Korea within days, after a government minister ruled they could not stay.

Reverend Wan Shin, 45, who gives sermons at Holy Trinity Church in Sutton, said he was “devastated” to leave the community he has lived and served in for the last eight years.

His sons, Hyun, 19, a student at Overton Grange School, and Joon, a former Wallington Grammar School student, can speak minimal Korean and are worried about undergoing mandatory military service.

Wife Ju Young Kim, 45, who works at the Oasis restaurant at Trinity Church, is equally distraught.

Mr Shin’s appeals to stay were consistently rejected by Home Office officials, with a final appeal rejected by a High Court judge before Christmas.

A community campaign with a 175-strong petition, and intervention from Sutton and Cheam MP Paul Burstow, failed to convince Immigration Minister Phil Woolas to let them stay last week.

Rev Shin, an ordained minister of the conservative Korean Evangelical Holiness Church, now fears he will no longer be able to work in Korea, after his views were significantly liberalised since worshipping at Holy Trinity – a United Reformed Methodist Church.

He said: “We have been in shock, nobody is OK.

“In South Korea there is not as much freedom as there is here; the churches there are quite narrow-minded.

“I’m not sure if I can adapt myself back to it, but I have no other employable skills.”

Rev Shin originally came from Seoul to the UK on an educational visa, so he could study for a degree at the University of Wales.

When it expired, the family immediately began making an application for permanent residency, while Rev Shin continued to work voluntarily at Holy Trinity Church.

The judge in the review case said both children were over 18, and their age could not be legally regarded as grounds to stay.

He said: “I’m worried the Korean system won’t recognise my sons’ qualifications here and they will be left behind.”

MP for Sutton and Cheam Paul Burstow said: “I’m disappointed to get the news, and also to be the bearer of the bad news to the family, as I think they have a compelling case.”

Trinity Church Rev Martin Camroux said Rev Shin was a valuable asset to the church community and would have made a “real contribution to multicultural ministry”.

Tony Smith, Regional Director of the UK Border Agency in London and the South East said the immigration system was “humane and compassionate”.

He said: “We would much rather that those families with no right to be in the country left voluntarily.

“Where people refuse to leave, however, it is our responsibility to enforce the decisions of the courts and send them home.”


Your Say YourComet

theavengers, sutton says...
7:58am Fri 5 Feb 10

Too many exploit our system and use a student visa to get into this country to remain which is well known to be illegal. They may be nice people but a crime is a crime and this happens everyday. England is a very small country and we can't have people taking advantage of us for their own gain.

Snork, Carshalton says...
9:13am Fri 5 Feb 10

So a respected charity worker and asset to our community gets sent back but if he had raped, shot or stabbed someone he'd no doubt be allowed to stay? This country is mad :(

SarahOX14, says...
9:54am Fri 5 Feb 10

Despite living in Sutton for eight years, Mrs. Ju Young Kim has failed to learn enough English to practise as a qualified social worker (Source: Sutton Guardian 15 Jan 2010)

How can she expect to be granted leave to remain here when she's made so little effort to become part of British society?

Mr Wan Shin may well be respected, but being respected doesn't mean the fact his educational visa has now expired and he's no longer in any form of education should be ignored.

He came here to study, not preach. It seems to me that he's been abusing the system long enough.

I hope not, Sutton says...
11:06am Fri 5 Feb 10

I am totally gutted for this wonderful family, this is a travesty. They haev come here, they work hard, they contribute to the community, they are well liked and are an asset to this country, yet scumbags who commit offences are allowed to stay.
We should be welcoming people who enrich our country, not shoving them out of the door. We have enough shirkers of our own living in this country, sitting on their backsides grabbing whatever benefit they can get, then we have the illegal immigrants, who come here and extort the system for whatever they can get out of us. This family is exactly the kind that I want in this country, hard working and good people. I am ashamed that we are turning them away, whilst keeping the filth here and that includes our own home grown losers.

SarahOX14, says...
11:11am Fri 5 Feb 10

They may be very nice and hard working but they have outstayed the terms of an educational visa (getting eight years here to do a degree is pretty good going considering degrees rarely last more than four years) and they don't have skills which the country has a desperate shortage of.

We can't allow every visitor who likes it here to stay just because they're nice.

Snork, Carshalton says...
1:59pm Mon 8 Feb 10

We allow many other immigrants to abuse the system in far worse ways than this family and let them stay. Why should a law abiding Korean visitor not be more welcome to stay than say a Polish builder who drives an unroadworthy van with no tax or insurance, no understanding of English building regulations and who goes on to knock down and kill someone?
I think the skills of a religious preacher are far more needed in this country than we might think

adrianshort, Sutton says...
5:19pm Mon 8 Feb 10

Snork,

Poland is in the EU and South Korea is not.

EU citizens have a right to live and work in other EU countries such as the UK. Rightly or wrongly, such people are not treated as "immigrants" in this country.

Of course, everyone in this country, regardless of citizenship or status is obliged to follow the law. In the case of this family, that means the law on student visas.

Comments are closed on this article.

Joon Suk Shin, Hyun Joon Shin, Ju Young Kim and Wan Shig Shin have lost their appeal and must now leave the country Joon Suk Shin, Hyun Joon Shin, Ju Young Kim and Wan Shig Shin have lost their appeal and must now leave the country

Local Links

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »