News RSS Feed


- Email photos and videos or text keyword SLNEWS with your message/photo/video to 80360.
- Sign up for Surrey Comets's free email bulletins.
- Comment Register now to post your comments.
follow us:Twitter

Animal campaigners call on Kingston Council to ban goldfish fair prizes


Animal lovers are demanding Kingston Council bans goldfish being given as prizes at fairs.

Christine Orton, 51, was left upset after seeing the pets being given away at Hook Fair last Saturday, July 18, believing the tradition was now illegal.

Under the Animal Welfare Act (2005) it is illegal to give a prize fish to an unaccompanied child under 16, but some councils have banned it altogether on their land after pressure from animal rights activists.

Mrs Orton said she was disgusted Kingston Council had not followed suit and mocked up a picture of Kingston’s three fish logo with three dead fish in protest.

She said: "Considering three fish have been Kingston’s logo for hundreds of years, it’s absolutely horrendous that Kingston Council can’t do something for other fish.

"Fish are living beings. A lot of people forget that they have feelings like a furry cat or a hairy dog.

"The fairs keep them in unacceptable condition, they ferry them around with only a little bit of air. The stall holders can’t see where the fish is going or what is happening to it.

"They need to make you aware that you’re going to have a duty of care and that you have the right home for it and tell you what to do if it gets sick."

Mrs Orton and partner Kieran Kirk, of York Way, Chessington, confronted organisers Surbiton Rotary Club at the fair on King Edward recreation ground and called the RSPCA for guidance on the law.

She added: "It did cast a bit of a black cloud over the day because you couldn’t help thinking how many of these fish were going to make it to the next day."

Rotary Club President Malcolm Finn said the law was not broken at Saturday’s fair but the moral issues over whether to allow live animals again will be decided before next year’s fair.

He said he was not aware the stall holder had goldfish as prizes until he arrived on the day.

A Kingston Council spokesman said: "While the council can stipulate how its own land and property may be used by hirers, as a Licensing Authority the council cannot attach a condition prohibiting the giving of animals as prizes on any premises that it licenses."

• What do you think? Let us know by email here, phone the newsdesk on 020 8330 9555 or leave a comment below.


Your Say YourComet

Wibblechick, Chessington says...
10:23am Sun 26 Jul 09

Thank you, Surrey Comet, for taking this matter seriously. Fish are sentient beings, just like mammals.

This should now bring the matter back into public awareness - and I doubt we will see this happen again :)

Daisymac, Great Missenden says...
11:06am Sun 26 Jul 09

Well Done Surrey Comet for highlighting this. What awful animal cruelty to be happening at a family event, I hope the Rotary Club have taken this onboard and will not repeat this terrible incident.

That Mad Wibblechick Woman, Wibblechick Village says...
11:20am Sun 26 Jul 09

Well done, Lets keep the pressure on and end this horrible praactice.

janek, says...
11:29am Sun 26 Jul 09

Well done for highlighting this issue Surrey Comet and to Christine for bringing this to their attention.

Hopefully this sad practice will soon be stopped!

Fred1, Surbiton says...
12:32pm Sun 26 Jul 09

Right. Goldfish. Moral issue. It's not like there's any war, corruption, human rights abuses or third world poverty going on, is there?

Who exactly is it who is wanting to play these games where goldfish are being offered as prizes anyway? And what kind of games are they?

If the animal rights activists want to make fools of themselves by doing something off their own backs, then that's fine by me. But I will *not* stand to one side and allow local authorities to waste our hard-earned council tax money during this time of recession on the enforcement of something so utterly trivial. Sorry, but I think that the homeless (and our tax money) has got to come before the fish.


ellimari, says...
1:52pm Sun 26 Jul 09

It wouldn't be seen as acceptable to give away baby rabbits as prizes and yet fish have been proven to be intelligent, and able to learn. In this day and age it is embarrassing to hear that we still feel we have the right to hand out living creatures like this.

We need to think harder and drag ourselves up the evolutionary ladder a bit if we are to justify being called a civilised community.

chiarain, Chessington says...
2:17pm Sun 26 Jul 09

Fred1,
Suggest you contact the Chief Executive, Bruce Mcdonald and the District Auditor regarding this "waste of public money".
Your concerns about homelessness should be addressed to the Head of Housing, Mike England.

Cat Lady, says...
2:20pm Sun 26 Jul 09

Although there are other "more pressing" moral issues, I feel that using goldfish or indeed any living thing as a prize to be won is unethical. I think this should be covered by the animal welfare act and it should be accorded appropriately to encompass this matter.

Cat Lady, says...
2:32pm Sun 26 Jul 09

Oops - that was meant to read "ammended appropriately."

madaboutfish, Carmarthen says...
3:45pm Sun 26 Jul 09

It is totally wrong that any living being should be given as prizes at fairs and This should be banned immediately.

Set an example to those who have no feelings and show that you as a council care.

Pinkfish, says...
4:51pm Sun 26 Jul 09

It's not hard or complicated to add a clause forbidding council land or facilities from being used to give away animals. They just can't be bothered to amend the license.

Democracy is wonderful! You council guys are all fired. You have 3 years notice. Leave the keys under the matt as you go... Fred, democracy is about governing by consensus and the consensus is that you don't make policy. Yours is the only voice against protecting and upholding a democratically written law - the 2006 Animal Welfare Act.

If complying with the Animal Welfare Act was such a problem for anyone, why didn't they speak up at the time of debate? Too late! The law is the law and Kingston council have a duty of care to its residents to avoid breaking it.

Daisymac, Great Missenden says...
5:50pm Sun 26 Jul 09

Fred1, when you volunteer to be put in a huge plastic bag with one inch of water and be offered up as a prize for pin the tail on the donkey, we will take your opinions on board.

Blip, Fulham says...
5:54pm Sun 26 Jul 09

Giving away living beings as prizes predates our modern science-based understanding of suffering.

To those who believe there are other pressing issues in the world: yes there are. But we don't have to solve the world's problems consecutively: we can deal with them concurrently, I suggest.

Comments are closed on this article.


Read more news...

Local Links

Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »